Investigation Año IX - Nº 15 - 2015  
 
» THE NATURE OF ADVISORY OPINIONS IN MERCOSUR. COMPARATIVE ANALIYS WITH THE EUROPEAN UNION
By María del Pilar García Martínez, María de la Paz Herrera y Sabrina Victoria Olivera

Sumary

This paper attemps to establish similaritys and differences between advisory opinions under the Mercosur rules and the preliminary rulings of the European Union law. With this aim we make an explanation about the nature and mechanism of both concepts, and then we analyze them comparatively, using regulatory standars, doctrine and jurisprudence link to the topic. In conclusion we express that the legal nature of the advisory opinions in Mercosur is different from the preliminary rulings in the European Union: they differ in their compulsory and binding nature for the judges who have asked it. However, both are similar in their objetives: ensuring the unity of law and the uniformity in their interpretation and application.

Key words

Advisory opinion - preliminary ruling - Mercosur - European Union

Español | full text [.pdf]
Revista Electrónica Año I,  Nº 1
Descargar revista completa
 
 
Facultad de Derecho
Universidad de Buenos Aires
Facultad de Derecho (UBA)
Contáctenos:
Lunes a viernes de 9 a 20 hs. - 1er. piso - Av. Figueroa Alcorta 2263 (C1425CKB)
Teléfono: 054-11-4-809-5629/5632 - Mail: revistagioja@derecho.uba.ar